1 It was a time and place. So I'm pondering whether execs would consider creating a music Hall of Fame today. Would they spontaneously rise up and come together and say WE LIVED THROUGH SOMETHING SPECIAL, IT MUST BE MEMORIALIZED FOR ALL TIME! No. I don't think anybody thinks that. There's a business. There are some great acts. But culturally, it's not the same. How did it start? Well, we can talk about "Rocket 88," Sun Studios and Elvis, the progenitors. And then the mass market acceptance/bastardization of the idea in the late fifties/early sixties. Some standouts, like the Beach Boys and the Four Seasons, and some interesting tributaries, like surf music, which evolved into hot rod music, but we also had Bobby Rydell and Fabian and then, when we least expected it on this side of the pond... We got the Beatles. They were a known quantity in the U.K. Hell, they'd been at it for years! There are bootlegs of them performing in their teens. They'd paid their dues, honed their chops, and it all started out in the club. Most notably at the Cavern Club, but that was not the only one. The club experience never changes. The room stays the same, the acts come and go. There's a permanent sound system but no real production, maybe some lights to go along with the sound, but it's ultimately all about the sound, the pure sound, the act and the audience. You can't fake it in a club, the people are too close, it's too intimate, either you've got the goods or you don't. But if you have them... Those are the primordial events, not only for the act, but the audience. When you're at ground zero, experiencing an act live that you know will go on to stardom, because they're just that good. This is the antithesis of today. Where the penumbra has triumphed over the nougat. You've got a flurry of promotion online. That trumps the time spent working on the songs, the act. And at the major label level, you've got the smoothing, the soothing, the co-writers and remixers. No different from most Fortune 500 companies. This is a product, that must be honed for the marketplace. But that's not what happens in a club. So I'm sitting there in the dark. John Sykes has spoken his piece. We are here for a night of celebration. Bringing back the heroes of yore for one more kiss of life. Nothing could be further from the essence of rock and roll, which is one reason Oasis stayed away. It's not the Hall's fault, it's the music's fault. Image has trumped the music. The business has eclipsed the show. And it's definitely a show. Because once you graduate from the clubs, there's a level of professionalism... Not only is their production, images, maybe even choreography, but there are supporting musicians and hard drives. Such that the end result is as close to the record as they can get it. They call it live music, but it's built to a click track, to synchronize all the effects, both musical and visual. It's far from the club experience. And then U2 takes the stage last night. 2 In Devon Ivie's review of last night's show, she labeled Rick Rubin: "the super-producer you either love to hate or hate to love" https://apple.news/ABNV6lQNNQTOK4LksFUEUPQ Ain't that the truth. That's what we're looking for in the arts, someone to put into words or images that which we know but cannot articulate. He's everywhere, and there's something offensive about him. The grand poohbah. Acting ultra-cool and then fawning over Paul McCartney...a nice Jewish boy now dieted down to thinness with his affected white beard... I will give him credit, he showed up in his shorts, that's very rock and roll, but the reason I bring up Rick is because many people feel the same way about Bono. Not Edge. Not Larry. Not Adam. Just Bono. You wonder if he's ever a regular person. And even if you get him in conversation, can he let down the facade, make fun of himself. Such that U2 starts with one strike against them in many people's eyes, after Bono has hung with world leaders, he and therefore his band are too far from the street. And then last night... I knew they were opening, and I knew what they were playing, but what I was not prepared for was...IT WAS JUST THEM! It was palpable. It was riveting. These were four guys, three playing instruments, clearly defined, such that the whole thing together was rock and roll, but it wasn't a wash, as so much of today's modern music is, leaving no air to breathe, and a lot of live music...acts feel if they just turn it up loud enough, that will cover the mistakes. The audience will be overwhelmed, they'll feel the sound. I mean how many shows have you been to where unless you know the song already you can't pick it out live, it's nearly indecipherable noise. But not U2 last night. It was positively revelatory. A complete return to the garden. If not the Cavern Club, some hole in Ireland, a band with a vision giving its all trying to make it. They weren't even trying to overwhelm us. They were just doing their act. And the first song was from the new album, and there was a bit of stage production involving riot officers with shields and...the less mentioned the better. Especially since they were literally in back of the band. No, this was four guys, Bono covering the front of the stage, Edge actually moving a bit, but it was about the sound, not the antics. And then... "In the name of love What more in the name of love" I'm tingling as I write this. The band broke through with its marvelous first album, with the infectious "I Will Follow." The follow-up, "October," was not as good and didn't resonate commercially. But then came "War." And the video shot at Red Rocks. And U2 were embedded deeply into the firmament. They'd planted their flag, they were at the forefront. But "Sunday Bloody Sunday" didn't mean much to Americans, barely versed on their own history, never mind that of Ireland. But on the following album, "The Unforgettable Fire," came "(Pride) In the Name of Love." "One man come in the name of love One man come and go" Martin Luther King, this we could understand. But really, it's the intro, with Edge's riff, it sets it all up, then they fall into the groove, DO YOU KNOW WHAT IT'S LIKE TO HEAR THAT LIVE, FROM MERE FEET AWAY? This isn't an imitation, this is THE REAL THING! The exact record you know by heart, come alive. It's everything you want in a live experience, THIS IS ROCK AND ROLL! And if the show had ended after that...I would have been happy, for me that was the absolute peak. I mean they're firing on all cylinders for an insider crowd. The hoi polloi is in the back. It's not self-celebration, it's performance. They're not overdoing it, trying to convince us, by Bono standards, he's understated, not dominating, not mugging, not hogging the stage and attention. This is a band and, playing rock and roll. This is part of the long continuum of what this whole Hall of Fame is all about. Will it translate on television? When has live music ever done this? It's about being there. A bond with act and audience, the two together praying at the altar of the music, which hovers above. It's not about shooting selfies. You don't want to take your eyes off the performance, you don't want to break the mood. I found myself jumping to attention, thrusting my arm in the air, not wondering what anybody thought, and where I was sitting most people stayed seated, they're too self-conscious, they're worried about their image, and their foundation is in business, they are worried about the dollars and cents, and how many fall into their pocketbook. But the rest of us... This music, this rock and roll, touched everybody, it had a broad audience. But at the core there are true believers. And I am one. Those who've sacrificed our entire lives for this thing, that cannot be easily described, this feeling, when the music hits us not only do we feel no pain, we're inspired, thrilled to be alive, we never want this moment to end. But it does, and like a true addict, we keep on coming back for more. 3 Now you'll hear complaints that U2 opened with a new number. Get off your high horse. Remember when the Police opened the Grammys to promote their reunion tour? That's what people want to see. And yes, U2 is promoting a new album, but...if you read the "New York Times" interview, Bono was nearly humble, he knows you can't reach everybody, that dream is over. https://www.nytimes.com/2026/10/17/magazine/bono-and-the-edge-interview.html?unlocked_article_code=1.Q1E.xtMK.7_OEmepd5Jmj&smid=url-share So, on a night when four of the honored acts didn't even show up... Oasis? Those two are unpredictable, who knows what they'll ever do. And to be cynical, they wouldn't be inducted if it weren't for the reunion tour, they don't need the imprimatur of the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame. But I did miss Noel Gallagher showing up and insulting us with a few quips, that guy is definitely rock and roll. As for the vaunted tension between the two brothers, Liam is FIVE+ YEARS YOUNGER THAN NOEL! Can you imagine being in an act with your younger brother like that, when you're in your twenties? Stephen Wilson Jr. doing "Wonderwall"? Good in theory, not magic in practice. I get it, since the brothers weren't there, go with understated. Maybe "Champagne Supernova," but "Wonderwall" is a wash of sound... They should have switched performances, Stephen Wilson Jr. should have performed Iron Maiden's "Trooper" and the motley crew of Metallica, et al, should have done "Wonderwall." That's right, Iron Maiden wasn't there either. And funny how the video was all about Bruce Dickinson, when everybody on the inside knows it's Steve Harris's band. But they should have been there. As for the videos... They were true highlights. In the YouTube era you think you've seen everything, but these pieces were very well done, I could have watched them for even longer. And I knew they were coming from the right place when the one for Luther Vandross... I'm sitting there listening to Oprah, who sounds the same, but looks like a fraction of herself, waxing poetic. And I figure we're going to get the love Luther, the image, whereas I first heard about him, his initial breakthrough was on David Bowie's "Young Americans." But they covered that! And I knew little about Linda Creed. And the pieces on Arif and Fela Kuti...they were not just punching the clock, these were very good. Phil Collins... All you've got to know is the words they put up on the screen. Only three people have sold a hundred million records as a solo artist and as part of a group... Paul McCartney, Michael Jackson and... That's right, Phil. That's how big Phil Collins was. And he's survived, for this victory lap. But his life is a good illustration of how having everything doesn't give you everything, solve all your problems, and although he can barely walk, he's mentally acute, he says we haven't seen the last of him, and I hope this is true. As for Cynthia Erivo's performance of "In the Air Tonight"... There was nothing wrong with it, but it needed the richness, maybe the bombast, of a male voice, and even though Travis Barker played the drums...there should have been some tweaking of the amplification. At events like this we're looking for transcendent, goosebump moments... I guess I'm a big Phil Collins fan, I bought "Face Value" upon release because I was a Genesis fan, it was personal and far from an instant breakthrough, I owned it, it was Phil's inner pain, and someone else can sing the words, but having us believe them, that's another skill. 4 Oh, I could go performance by performance... Let's see, Jack Black introducing the Maiden tribute...this guy is always great. Did you see him in the video from the Sphere, rocking out to Metallica with Celine Dion? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3UWSgdezYzU The Peppers? I can't believe Flea can still jump around like that at his age, after doing it for so many years, especially after seeing Collins helped onto the stage, I wonder what's in Flea's future. And I'd be lying if I said I was the biggest Peppers fan. But, the Rick Rubin beards and glasses was funny. Queen Latifah and MC Lyte? There's no one who doesn't like Queen Latifah, although her speech did go on too long. But the production number with Lyte... The dancing worked, added a level of spectacle. Billy Idol? I guess I liked him more at the Aerosmith tribute. And the sound wasn't clean. And then came Wu-Tang. 5 Now to say I'm an expert would be laughable. But as Chris Rock said their deal allowed all nine members to make their own solo contracts, and the names were read... I was stunned I knew almost all of them. And Chris is so great, but he was reading from the teleprompter, I'd have preferred if he'd riffed off the cuff. But then the Clan took the stage... HOW CAN YOU MAKE ANY MONEY WITH THIS MANY GUYS IN THE GROUP? This was the essence of hip-hop, a posse, doing it together, a family. The only problem was they pulled an Oscars move and didn't let each member speak, which I thought was a mistake, not because it was a diss, but because these guys were saying the most interesting, honest, hysterical things. I mean you can cut it in post. As opposed to Neil Young, come out to honor Rick Rubin. They don't get any bigger than Neil. The old man who's done it his own way and survived. But this was the antithesis of Bob Dylan at Musicares, who dropped truth on us for fifteen minutes, proving he'd been paying attention all these years. Neil went on and on with this concept about protecting the music... I mean we got it, right away. Made you wonder if Neil had lost a step, or maybe he wasn't quite the seer you thought he was. I mean everybody can have a bad night, but this went on and on... As for Rick himself... He made it short and sweet, saying "You can't kill rock and roll." Only they have. Because it's gotten too far from its roots, too far from what U2 displayed in the opening. And just to hammer the point home, U2's image is all conceptual, in your mind, based on the sound, the music as opposed to outfits and posturing. They don't need no stinkin' leather jackets. They don't need to make over the top statements... They made it and survive on their music. Have some faux pas dented that image, absolutely, but that does not deny their power last night. Anyway... When Wu-Tang finally performs... Everybody's got a mic, there is no choreography, they're milling around on stage, one after another stepped forward, watching made you realize why hip-hop eclipsed rock. This was vital in a way those in spandex and today's active rockers are not. Leave out the artifice, have a sense of humor...if you get tattoos, spike up your hair and turn it up to 11...what makes you different from everybody else who's ever done this? Nothing. 6 They did the best with what they had. I mean Sade didn't show up either. Then again, where are you going to find acts with the essence of the progenitors, not only Chuck Berry and the Beatles, but the Kinks and the Yardbirds and... And it used to be an insider event, a party, and now it's made for television, and the best stuff in rock always happens off the record, in hotel rooms and clubs but mostly when the musicians are playing with nothing to prove to anybody but each other, when the paying customers are excluded, when they can let go and be themselves. And a lot of your heroes are not people you want to meet, never mind hang with. But they can do this one damn thing. And this one damn thing makes you believe. There's a power, and a glory. They call it rock and roll. -- Visit the archive: http://lefsetz.com/wordpress/ -- Listen to the podcast: -iHeart: https://ihr.fm/2Gi5PFj -Apple: https://apple.co/2ndmpvp -- http://www.twitter.com/lefsetz -- If you would like to subscribe to the LefsetzLetter, http://www.lefsetz.com/lists/?p=subscribe&id=1 If you do not want to receive any more LefsetzLetters, http://lefsetz.com/lists/?p=unsubscribe&uid=0eecea7b60b461717065cbde887c8e25 To change your email address http://lefsetz.com/lists/?p=preferences&uid=0eecea7b60b461717065cbde887c8e25