Tune in Saturday October 12th to Faction Talk, channel 103, at 4 PM East, 1 PM West.
If you miss the episode, you can hear it on demand on the SiriusXM app. Search: Lefsetz
--
Visit the archive: http://lefsetz.com/wordpress/
--
Listen to the podcast:
-iHeart: https://ihr.fm/2Gi5PFj
-Apple: https://apple.co/2ndmpvp
--
http://www.twitter.com/lefsetz
--
If you would like to subscribe to the LefsetzLetter,
http://www.lefsetz.com/lists/?p=subscribe&id=1
If you do not want to receive any more LefsetzLetters, http://lefsetz.com/lists/?p=unsubscribe&uid=0eecea7b60b461717065cbde887c8e25
To change your email address http://lefsetz.com/lists/?p=preferences&uid=0eecea7b60b461717065cbde887c8e25
Friday 11 October 2024
Thursday 10 October 2024
Tell Me Everything
https://shorturl.at/RdLfw
This is a fantastic book. (And easy to read too!)
For those of you not on the Strout train... You're the lucky ones, because you can go back and read all the books that preceded this one. If, like me, you're totally up to date, you'll be fascinated by the fact that seemingly every previous character plays a part in "Tell Me Everything."
In reality, it's all about style. And I can't say I can define it, but I'll try to relate the experience of reading the book.
It's set in the modern world, the world we live in, but really it's more like the world we used to live in prior to the internet. We're all overwhelmed with the election, social media, there's a tsunami of information, and although there are some proud Boomers who will tell you they've got flip phones and have never been on Instagram, never mind TikTok, most of us want to know what is going on, and we're drawn into the maelstrom.
Not that "Tell Me Everything" is set in a fantasy land.
Then again, it is set in Maine. And if you've been there, if you know people from there, you know Maine is in many ways behind, off the grid, don't compare it with its neighbor New Hampshire, never mind Vermont, it's a completely different culture.
And the map doesn't do the state justice. Maine is big! And although there is the city of Portland down south, and coastal towns, and summer people, the basic Mainer is iconoclastic, and oftentimes rugged, and definitely self-sufficient. They don't need you. Many are internalized, or part of a small community, and they're proud of this.
And some of the people in Crosby and Shirley Falls, where most of the action in the book takes place, are transplants, retirees, but most of them are locals. They know each other, they know everybody's story, they went to school together. I found this stifling when I lived in a small town, the pre-judging, the lack of anonymity, but you know many more people when you live in a hamlet, a small burg, than when you live in the city.
So, although there are references to the pandemic and the internet, "Tell Me Everything" is disconnected, and that's one of its appeals. It's a whole community, identity and history are important, wealth not so much. You're treated like a regular person, not that it's the land of kumbaya, everybody does not always agree, nor is everybody given the benefit of the doubt. But ultimately everybody intersects. If you think you're special, better than the rest, you won't make it in this book, or in Maine itself.
Unlike in many books, a lot happens in "Tell Me Everything." There is not endless description and setup. Not that it's bare bones. There's just enough description and...
What you've got here mostly is those who can see the end of life. Those fiftysomething and older. They interact with their children, or not, and at this late date they know who they are. They've made their choices, are they good ones?
And there's a murder mystery. And death from illness.
And a ton of family interactions.
But the overarching theme is a crush. Bob on Lucy. Is it reciprocated? Should Bob bring it up, should he take action?
Now in popular culture, everybody follows their heart, acts on a whim. But really... Especially after one divorce, you tend to learn what you're getting in your primary relationship, which may not be what your crush delivers, but to take action and "ruin" everybody's life and maybe find out you made a mistake... The grass does look greener on the other side. And, you don't know what you've got till it's gone. But we're always running scenarios in our brain. And they're in this book.
And the question of obligation. Especially when you get older. Do you help those in need? The less mobile? In the city, those on the fast track will tell you they don't have time, that somebody should be hired, but in smaller communities...
Now despite being such an easy read, there's a ton of wisdom in the book.
"She's a bully, and bullies are always frightened."
I'd never thought of that, never mind known it. But contemplating it, it's true!
"That Bob had spoken these words to her remained a thumbprint pressed deeply into his soul of real sorrow and regret."
In this case it's something Bob said to his mother, who is deceased, and he can't let it go. There's so much I can't let go of. The scenarios run in my brain, what I said and what I did. And I'm old enough to know that the object of my pain may not even be aware of it. But one thing great about getting old is people eventually die, and you may never encounter them again, you don't feel that urge to contact them, you realize you're flawed and march to the end.
"People always tell you who they are if you just listen—they will always eventually tell you who they are."
Which is why you're better off asking questions and listening than talking, because people will tell you everything. And when it comes to romance, people tell you who they are very quickly, and don't expect them to change.
"There is nothing sexier than talking."
I had a shrink who got frustrated with me and said I'd rather talk to women than screw them. (That's almost a direct quote!) I guess... I never feel confident enough. They'd want to roll in the hay with ME?
I was at a friend's house a while back, and I had a long conversation with a woman who is a household name, but is not an entertainer. She was famous for a while, and if you were alive when that happened... And I felt a connection, but it couldn't have been reciprocated, right?
Almost ten years later I went to someone's house, and she was one of about thirty people there. And I avoided her. That's what I do when I have feelings, I'm just too anxious. You'll know I'm interested by the fact that I'm not connecting with you when we're in the same space. And then, after dinner, after dessert, when the evening was winding down, this woman came up and said...AREN'T YOU GOING TO TALK TO ME?
I was completely blown away. I was busy apologizing. After all this time, I figured she'd never remember. But she looked me in the eye and started talking about everything we'd said years before. She felt it too, who knew?
Yes, you can call "Tell Me Everything" literary fiction. But it's not from the Iowa Workshop, Elizabeth Strout was not trained by everybody else, and that's one reason her work is so good. It's not overwritten. All her books flow, quickly. She seems to be writing for herself, with a need to tell these stories as opposed to needing to impress some fictional high priests. Strout was a lawyer and then...
You don't have to have read any Strout books to enjoy "Tell Me Everything." And it's not a huge commitment, it's not long, never mind dreary, but there will come a point where you'll start regretting it's going to end, you want to live with this book forever.
And if you tell me you saw the dramatization of "Olive Kitteridge" on HBO...
Well, as great as Frances McDormand is, I don't see her as Olive at all. And a film or a series can't convey what is so great about books...feelings, interior dialogue.
Now it's not like I'm the only person raving about "Tell Me Everything."
And if you're male and a fan of nonfiction only, I'm not going to tell you to run out and buy it...
But the truth is if you're human, with some level of self-knowledge, you're going to get caught up in, become enraptured by "Tell Me Everything," really all of Strout's books.
"Tell Me Everything" is for everybody. It's not a fantastical adventure, but real life.
And that's what we're all doing, living life, just like the characters in this book.
--
Visit the archive: http://lefsetz.com/wordpress/
--
Listen to the podcast:
-iHeart: https://ihr.fm/2Gi5PFj
-Apple: https://apple.co/2ndmpvp
--
http://www.twitter.com/lefsetz
--
If you would like to subscribe to the LefsetzLetter,
http://www.lefsetz.com/lists/?p=subscribe&id=1
If you do not want to receive any more LefsetzLetters, http://lefsetz.com/lists/?p=unsubscribe&uid=0eecea7b60b461717065cbde887c8e25
To change your email address http://lefsetz.com/lists/?p=preferences&uid=0eecea7b60b461717065cbde887c8e25
This is a fantastic book. (And easy to read too!)
For those of you not on the Strout train... You're the lucky ones, because you can go back and read all the books that preceded this one. If, like me, you're totally up to date, you'll be fascinated by the fact that seemingly every previous character plays a part in "Tell Me Everything."
In reality, it's all about style. And I can't say I can define it, but I'll try to relate the experience of reading the book.
It's set in the modern world, the world we live in, but really it's more like the world we used to live in prior to the internet. We're all overwhelmed with the election, social media, there's a tsunami of information, and although there are some proud Boomers who will tell you they've got flip phones and have never been on Instagram, never mind TikTok, most of us want to know what is going on, and we're drawn into the maelstrom.
Not that "Tell Me Everything" is set in a fantasy land.
Then again, it is set in Maine. And if you've been there, if you know people from there, you know Maine is in many ways behind, off the grid, don't compare it with its neighbor New Hampshire, never mind Vermont, it's a completely different culture.
And the map doesn't do the state justice. Maine is big! And although there is the city of Portland down south, and coastal towns, and summer people, the basic Mainer is iconoclastic, and oftentimes rugged, and definitely self-sufficient. They don't need you. Many are internalized, or part of a small community, and they're proud of this.
And some of the people in Crosby and Shirley Falls, where most of the action in the book takes place, are transplants, retirees, but most of them are locals. They know each other, they know everybody's story, they went to school together. I found this stifling when I lived in a small town, the pre-judging, the lack of anonymity, but you know many more people when you live in a hamlet, a small burg, than when you live in the city.
So, although there are references to the pandemic and the internet, "Tell Me Everything" is disconnected, and that's one of its appeals. It's a whole community, identity and history are important, wealth not so much. You're treated like a regular person, not that it's the land of kumbaya, everybody does not always agree, nor is everybody given the benefit of the doubt. But ultimately everybody intersects. If you think you're special, better than the rest, you won't make it in this book, or in Maine itself.
Unlike in many books, a lot happens in "Tell Me Everything." There is not endless description and setup. Not that it's bare bones. There's just enough description and...
What you've got here mostly is those who can see the end of life. Those fiftysomething and older. They interact with their children, or not, and at this late date they know who they are. They've made their choices, are they good ones?
And there's a murder mystery. And death from illness.
And a ton of family interactions.
But the overarching theme is a crush. Bob on Lucy. Is it reciprocated? Should Bob bring it up, should he take action?
Now in popular culture, everybody follows their heart, acts on a whim. But really... Especially after one divorce, you tend to learn what you're getting in your primary relationship, which may not be what your crush delivers, but to take action and "ruin" everybody's life and maybe find out you made a mistake... The grass does look greener on the other side. And, you don't know what you've got till it's gone. But we're always running scenarios in our brain. And they're in this book.
And the question of obligation. Especially when you get older. Do you help those in need? The less mobile? In the city, those on the fast track will tell you they don't have time, that somebody should be hired, but in smaller communities...
Now despite being such an easy read, there's a ton of wisdom in the book.
"She's a bully, and bullies are always frightened."
I'd never thought of that, never mind known it. But contemplating it, it's true!
"That Bob had spoken these words to her remained a thumbprint pressed deeply into his soul of real sorrow and regret."
In this case it's something Bob said to his mother, who is deceased, and he can't let it go. There's so much I can't let go of. The scenarios run in my brain, what I said and what I did. And I'm old enough to know that the object of my pain may not even be aware of it. But one thing great about getting old is people eventually die, and you may never encounter them again, you don't feel that urge to contact them, you realize you're flawed and march to the end.
"People always tell you who they are if you just listen—they will always eventually tell you who they are."
Which is why you're better off asking questions and listening than talking, because people will tell you everything. And when it comes to romance, people tell you who they are very quickly, and don't expect them to change.
"There is nothing sexier than talking."
I had a shrink who got frustrated with me and said I'd rather talk to women than screw them. (That's almost a direct quote!) I guess... I never feel confident enough. They'd want to roll in the hay with ME?
I was at a friend's house a while back, and I had a long conversation with a woman who is a household name, but is not an entertainer. She was famous for a while, and if you were alive when that happened... And I felt a connection, but it couldn't have been reciprocated, right?
Almost ten years later I went to someone's house, and she was one of about thirty people there. And I avoided her. That's what I do when I have feelings, I'm just too anxious. You'll know I'm interested by the fact that I'm not connecting with you when we're in the same space. And then, after dinner, after dessert, when the evening was winding down, this woman came up and said...AREN'T YOU GOING TO TALK TO ME?
I was completely blown away. I was busy apologizing. After all this time, I figured she'd never remember. But she looked me in the eye and started talking about everything we'd said years before. She felt it too, who knew?
Yes, you can call "Tell Me Everything" literary fiction. But it's not from the Iowa Workshop, Elizabeth Strout was not trained by everybody else, and that's one reason her work is so good. It's not overwritten. All her books flow, quickly. She seems to be writing for herself, with a need to tell these stories as opposed to needing to impress some fictional high priests. Strout was a lawyer and then...
You don't have to have read any Strout books to enjoy "Tell Me Everything." And it's not a huge commitment, it's not long, never mind dreary, but there will come a point where you'll start regretting it's going to end, you want to live with this book forever.
And if you tell me you saw the dramatization of "Olive Kitteridge" on HBO...
Well, as great as Frances McDormand is, I don't see her as Olive at all. And a film or a series can't convey what is so great about books...feelings, interior dialogue.
Now it's not like I'm the only person raving about "Tell Me Everything."
And if you're male and a fan of nonfiction only, I'm not going to tell you to run out and buy it...
But the truth is if you're human, with some level of self-knowledge, you're going to get caught up in, become enraptured by "Tell Me Everything," really all of Strout's books.
"Tell Me Everything" is for everybody. It's not a fantastical adventure, but real life.
And that's what we're all doing, living life, just like the characters in this book.
--
Visit the archive: http://lefsetz.com/wordpress/
--
Listen to the podcast:
-iHeart: https://ihr.fm/2Gi5PFj
-Apple: https://apple.co/2ndmpvp
--
http://www.twitter.com/lefsetz
--
If you would like to subscribe to the LefsetzLetter,
http://www.lefsetz.com/lists/?p=subscribe&id=1
If you do not want to receive any more LefsetzLetters, http://lefsetz.com/lists/?p=unsubscribe&uid=0eecea7b60b461717065cbde887c8e25
To change your email address http://lefsetz.com/lists/?p=preferences&uid=0eecea7b60b461717065cbde887c8e25
Alynda Segarra-This Week's Podcast
Alynda Segarra is the front person and major creative force of Hurray for the Riff-Raff. Listen as they tell the tale of dropping out of high school, riding the rails, moving to New Orleans, starting as a pure indie, and then moving to ATO and ultimately Nonesuch, changing musical direction along the way. You may not know their music, but you'll want to after listening to this podcast!
https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/alynda-segarra/id1316200737?i=1000672490558
https://open.spotify.com/episode/597OLryO0hyyqM2Gp01TL4?si=LIwCs8w1Rd26Zcv2d20ZBg
https://www.iheart.com/podcast/1119-the-bob-lefsetz-podcast-30806836/episode/alynda-segarra-225723448/
https://music.amazon.com/podcasts/9ff4fb19-54d4-41ae-ae7a-8a6f8d3dafa8/episodes/f959382e-fc88-4416-9ee6-2946b0beb1e2/the-bob-lefsetz-podcast-alynda-segarra
--
Visit the archive: http://lefsetz.com/wordpress/
--
Listen to the podcast:
-iHeart: https://ihr.fm/2Gi5PFj
-Apple: https://apple.co/2ndmpvp
--
http://www.twitter.com/lefsetz
--
If you would like to subscribe to the LefsetzLetter,
http://www.lefsetz.com/lists/?p=subscribe&id=1
If you do not want to receive any more LefsetzLetters, http://lefsetz.com/lists/?p=unsubscribe&uid=0eecea7b60b461717065cbde887c8e25
To change your email address http://lefsetz.com/lists/?p=preferences&uid=0eecea7b60b461717065cbde887c8e25
https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/alynda-segarra/id1316200737?i=1000672490558
https://open.spotify.com/episode/597OLryO0hyyqM2Gp01TL4?si=LIwCs8w1Rd26Zcv2d20ZBg
https://www.iheart.com/podcast/1119-the-bob-lefsetz-podcast-30806836/episode/alynda-segarra-225723448/
https://music.amazon.com/podcasts/9ff4fb19-54d4-41ae-ae7a-8a6f8d3dafa8/episodes/f959382e-fc88-4416-9ee6-2946b0beb1e2/the-bob-lefsetz-podcast-alynda-segarra
--
Visit the archive: http://lefsetz.com/wordpress/
--
Listen to the podcast:
-iHeart: https://ihr.fm/2Gi5PFj
-Apple: https://apple.co/2ndmpvp
--
http://www.twitter.com/lefsetz
--
If you would like to subscribe to the LefsetzLetter,
http://www.lefsetz.com/lists/?p=subscribe&id=1
If you do not want to receive any more LefsetzLetters, http://lefsetz.com/lists/?p=unsubscribe&uid=0eecea7b60b461717065cbde887c8e25
To change your email address http://lefsetz.com/lists/?p=preferences&uid=0eecea7b60b461717065cbde887c8e25
Wednesday 9 October 2024
Ten Years Gone
The modern music business was built on album tracks.
The single is just the introduction. The key is to set the listener on an adventure, deep into the wilderness. It's a solo journey. If you need friends, a crowd, dancers to enjoy a track, that's something different. It may be joyful, but that's not what built this business into the juggernaut it became.
Sure, rock and roll started in the fifties. But not long thereafter it devolved...into what it's become today. Empty stars, most of whom have been forgotten, are completely unknown to today's youngsters. Fabian? Bobby Rydell? They were ultimately eclipsed by the Beatles. Sure, we had the Beach Boys and the Four Seasons, but when the Beatles hit the airwaves at the advent of 1964, everything changed. It was no longer music, it was MANIA! Music suddenly became everything. And sure, the four from Liverpool were cute, had good voices, and were cheeky, but really it was all about the music. Which they wrote. That was the turning point. Suddenly, the music was direct from them to you, the artist to the listener, ideas, truth, beauty were being channeled directly into your heart.
And then came FM radio. Everybody who'd been inspired by the Beatles, everybody too left field for the mainstream, everybody who thought music was more than a cut on a 45 RPM single, suddenly had an outlet for their work. Listeners were exposed to "Purple Haze" and "Sunshine of Your Love," the latter of which ultimately crossed over to AM with its iconic riff, but my favorite track on "Disraeli Gears" has always been "Tales of Brave Ulysses." And if I want to listen to Hendrix, I'll put on "Burning of the Midnight Lamp."
I'm not saying cuts didn't cross over to AM, you could hear "Piece of My Heart" there, but so much of the great stuff, that could sell tickets, never produced a single. This is the stuff you remember. Funny how all these years later everybody agrees that the first Blood, Sweat & Tears album is far superior to the follow-up with David Clayton Thomas that produced all those hits. Furthermore, the band could never follow up that monster, whereas Al Kooper continued to have a career, I bought the albums he made/was involved with, whereas the rap on "Blood, Sweat & Tears 3" was so bad I left it in the bins. Can you say "Hi-De-Ho"? No!
And as the seventies wore on, every hamlet and burg got an FM station, if you were listening to AM you were a loser. An act could be huge on FM and be completely unknown on AM.
If you look at the "Billboard" chart, and I advise against it, you'll see that "Free Bird" made it all the way to #19 on the singles chart, but really it was an FM staple, always #2 on the annual Memorial Day 500, the best songs of rock history. And the perennial #1, "Stairway to Heaven," was never a single, never ever. Nor was there a truncated version. You accepted the track as is, or...
Meanwhile, I've skipped over "Stairway to Heaven" many times while listening to the fourth Zeppelin LP. If I listen to that album I want to hear "Battle of Evermore" or "Going to California" or..."When the Levee Breaks." And "D'yer Mak'er" was one of the worst songs on "Houses of the Holy." If I'm looking for obvious, I'll go with "Dancing Days," and "The Rain Song" and "Over the Hills and Far Away" eclipse both. Where is the spot on AM radio for the mysterious, atmospheric "The Rain Song"? Talk about not being a single.
But these were the songs you wanted to hear live.
And for a long time I swore that the first Zeppelin album was the best.
I can't say I wasn't enamored of the opening banger "Good Times Bad Times," and "Communication Breakdown" was a tear, but my favorite song on the debut is "Dazed and Confused." And then "Your Time Is Gonna Come" and "How Many More Times."
And to tell you the truth, by time "Physical Graffiti" was released in the spring of 1975, I was off Zeppelin, the fifth album wasn't as good as the fourth and it was more obvious and embraced by the hoi polloi and then...
I heard "Kashmir.'
Not on the radio, but as part of the album. A friend had made an 8-track tape that he played in the condo every day when we got home from skiing that month of May at Mammoth Mountain.
Now "Kashmir" was usually #3 in those Memorial Day countdowns, which evaporated with the demise of AOR radio, but it was never a single. As a matter of fact, nothing on "Physical Graffiti" was ever heard on AM radio! This was an hour and twenty minute listening experience. And certain tracks didn't really work out of context. "Down by the Seaside" was so great because it sat on the third side between "Bron-Yr-Aur" and "Ten Years Gone."
And "Ten Years Gone" is the piece-de-resistance!
I was stunned when I heard the band play it live. But really, it's always been a private listening experience. In the dark. On headphones. "Ten Years Gone" is not background music, it demands attention, not by banging you over the head, but via subtlety, via magic.
And majesty.
"Ten Years Gone" is a symphonic work. It's not something that you talk about, but it is something you think about, sing in your head, play on a regular basis.
And in the eighties the mainstream and the outside merged on MTV. The lame AM hits were replaced by FM-style hits, but it was all about single cuts on the music video service. And to hear them at home you had to buy the album, and radio played what MTV did, there were new Top Fortys replicating the MTV playlist which eclipsed FM, and the overpriced CD came along and suddenly record companies, and their executives, were richer than ever before.
And it hasn't been the same since.
Even worse, those with knowledge of the switch from AM to FM, from singles to album rock, are in the rearview mirror. Most people in the business, never mind listeners, only know single driven music.
To our collective detriment.
But in the past decade something has changed. As the major labels keep consolidating, trying to launch hit singles, those who desire a deeper meaning, a deeper feeling, have moved on to acts that are not giant, but deliver the feeling of yore, the heart of both music and the business. We want more than the track, and in order for the business to be healthy this is the way it has to be.
People have not lost the need to hear "Ten Years Gone," it just hasn't been served to them. And I'd love to tell you they're making new "Ten Years Gone," but that's why they call it classic rock.
Our only hope is that some of these outside acts, doing it on their own, without Jack Antonoff and cowriters, will hone their chops to the point where they create undeniable music, which can then spread.
The seeds have been planted. The only way out of this mess is to go back to the garden. That's where the optimism lies. Because the experience never changes, it's what people desire, and if it's not delivered music will continue to be a second-class citizen. But for a while there, especially from "Rubber Soul" to "The Wall," it was...
EVERYTHING!
--
Visit the archive: http://lefsetz.com/wordpress/
--
Listen to the podcast:
-iHeart: https://ihr.fm/2Gi5PFj
-Apple: https://apple.co/2ndmpvp
--
http://www.twitter.com/lefsetz
--
If you would like to subscribe to the LefsetzLetter,
http://www.lefsetz.com/lists/?p=subscribe&id=1
If you do not want to receive any more LefsetzLetters, http://lefsetz.com/lists/?p=unsubscribe&uid=0eecea7b60b461717065cbde887c8e25
To change your email address http://lefsetz.com/lists/?p=preferences&uid=0eecea7b60b461717065cbde887c8e25
The single is just the introduction. The key is to set the listener on an adventure, deep into the wilderness. It's a solo journey. If you need friends, a crowd, dancers to enjoy a track, that's something different. It may be joyful, but that's not what built this business into the juggernaut it became.
Sure, rock and roll started in the fifties. But not long thereafter it devolved...into what it's become today. Empty stars, most of whom have been forgotten, are completely unknown to today's youngsters. Fabian? Bobby Rydell? They were ultimately eclipsed by the Beatles. Sure, we had the Beach Boys and the Four Seasons, but when the Beatles hit the airwaves at the advent of 1964, everything changed. It was no longer music, it was MANIA! Music suddenly became everything. And sure, the four from Liverpool were cute, had good voices, and were cheeky, but really it was all about the music. Which they wrote. That was the turning point. Suddenly, the music was direct from them to you, the artist to the listener, ideas, truth, beauty were being channeled directly into your heart.
And then came FM radio. Everybody who'd been inspired by the Beatles, everybody too left field for the mainstream, everybody who thought music was more than a cut on a 45 RPM single, suddenly had an outlet for their work. Listeners were exposed to "Purple Haze" and "Sunshine of Your Love," the latter of which ultimately crossed over to AM with its iconic riff, but my favorite track on "Disraeli Gears" has always been "Tales of Brave Ulysses." And if I want to listen to Hendrix, I'll put on "Burning of the Midnight Lamp."
I'm not saying cuts didn't cross over to AM, you could hear "Piece of My Heart" there, but so much of the great stuff, that could sell tickets, never produced a single. This is the stuff you remember. Funny how all these years later everybody agrees that the first Blood, Sweat & Tears album is far superior to the follow-up with David Clayton Thomas that produced all those hits. Furthermore, the band could never follow up that monster, whereas Al Kooper continued to have a career, I bought the albums he made/was involved with, whereas the rap on "Blood, Sweat & Tears 3" was so bad I left it in the bins. Can you say "Hi-De-Ho"? No!
And as the seventies wore on, every hamlet and burg got an FM station, if you were listening to AM you were a loser. An act could be huge on FM and be completely unknown on AM.
If you look at the "Billboard" chart, and I advise against it, you'll see that "Free Bird" made it all the way to #19 on the singles chart, but really it was an FM staple, always #2 on the annual Memorial Day 500, the best songs of rock history. And the perennial #1, "Stairway to Heaven," was never a single, never ever. Nor was there a truncated version. You accepted the track as is, or...
Meanwhile, I've skipped over "Stairway to Heaven" many times while listening to the fourth Zeppelin LP. If I listen to that album I want to hear "Battle of Evermore" or "Going to California" or..."When the Levee Breaks." And "D'yer Mak'er" was one of the worst songs on "Houses of the Holy." If I'm looking for obvious, I'll go with "Dancing Days," and "The Rain Song" and "Over the Hills and Far Away" eclipse both. Where is the spot on AM radio for the mysterious, atmospheric "The Rain Song"? Talk about not being a single.
But these were the songs you wanted to hear live.
And for a long time I swore that the first Zeppelin album was the best.
I can't say I wasn't enamored of the opening banger "Good Times Bad Times," and "Communication Breakdown" was a tear, but my favorite song on the debut is "Dazed and Confused." And then "Your Time Is Gonna Come" and "How Many More Times."
And to tell you the truth, by time "Physical Graffiti" was released in the spring of 1975, I was off Zeppelin, the fifth album wasn't as good as the fourth and it was more obvious and embraced by the hoi polloi and then...
I heard "Kashmir.'
Not on the radio, but as part of the album. A friend had made an 8-track tape that he played in the condo every day when we got home from skiing that month of May at Mammoth Mountain.
Now "Kashmir" was usually #3 in those Memorial Day countdowns, which evaporated with the demise of AOR radio, but it was never a single. As a matter of fact, nothing on "Physical Graffiti" was ever heard on AM radio! This was an hour and twenty minute listening experience. And certain tracks didn't really work out of context. "Down by the Seaside" was so great because it sat on the third side between "Bron-Yr-Aur" and "Ten Years Gone."
And "Ten Years Gone" is the piece-de-resistance!
I was stunned when I heard the band play it live. But really, it's always been a private listening experience. In the dark. On headphones. "Ten Years Gone" is not background music, it demands attention, not by banging you over the head, but via subtlety, via magic.
And majesty.
"Ten Years Gone" is a symphonic work. It's not something that you talk about, but it is something you think about, sing in your head, play on a regular basis.
And in the eighties the mainstream and the outside merged on MTV. The lame AM hits were replaced by FM-style hits, but it was all about single cuts on the music video service. And to hear them at home you had to buy the album, and radio played what MTV did, there were new Top Fortys replicating the MTV playlist which eclipsed FM, and the overpriced CD came along and suddenly record companies, and their executives, were richer than ever before.
And it hasn't been the same since.
Even worse, those with knowledge of the switch from AM to FM, from singles to album rock, are in the rearview mirror. Most people in the business, never mind listeners, only know single driven music.
To our collective detriment.
But in the past decade something has changed. As the major labels keep consolidating, trying to launch hit singles, those who desire a deeper meaning, a deeper feeling, have moved on to acts that are not giant, but deliver the feeling of yore, the heart of both music and the business. We want more than the track, and in order for the business to be healthy this is the way it has to be.
People have not lost the need to hear "Ten Years Gone," it just hasn't been served to them. And I'd love to tell you they're making new "Ten Years Gone," but that's why they call it classic rock.
Our only hope is that some of these outside acts, doing it on their own, without Jack Antonoff and cowriters, will hone their chops to the point where they create undeniable music, which can then spread.
The seeds have been planted. The only way out of this mess is to go back to the garden. That's where the optimism lies. Because the experience never changes, it's what people desire, and if it's not delivered music will continue to be a second-class citizen. But for a while there, especially from "Rubber Soul" to "The Wall," it was...
EVERYTHING!
--
Visit the archive: http://lefsetz.com/wordpress/
--
Listen to the podcast:
-iHeart: https://ihr.fm/2Gi5PFj
-Apple: https://apple.co/2ndmpvp
--
http://www.twitter.com/lefsetz
--
If you would like to subscribe to the LefsetzLetter,
http://www.lefsetz.com/lists/?p=subscribe&id=1
If you do not want to receive any more LefsetzLetters, http://lefsetz.com/lists/?p=unsubscribe&uid=0eecea7b60b461717065cbde887c8e25
To change your email address http://lefsetz.com/lists/?p=preferences&uid=0eecea7b60b461717065cbde887c8e25
Monday 7 October 2024
Nobody Wants This
Trailer: https://t.ly/6rbTD
We watched this because Brooke Hammerling raved about it.
I was aware of the Netflix series, but the reviews said it missed the mark. The first few were negative, the next said the series was fun, but a trifle, and then I saw Brooke mention "Nobody Wants This" in Pop Culture Mondays. You can read it/sign up for it, here: https://popculturemondays.com
But let me just tell you, it's a lot of stuff. And if you're a social media hater, someone who believes the smartphone is best turned off, you'll scroll what Brooke has to say and be flummoxed, overwhelmed and ultimately dismissive. You see Brooke chronicles social media/internet trends.
Did you see those Frankie Valli videos?
I hadn't, although I did catch some of the aftermath after being hipped by Brooke.
You see Frankie Valli is 90 and still on the road. I heard over a decade ago that he lip-synchs, so I've avoided the show, because I love the Four Seasons, my mother bought "Big Girls Don't Cry" and that was just about the only pop record she ever purchased. And when the Beatles hit, the American acts that persevered, that got not only radio play but jukebox play, were the Four Seasons and the Beach Boys. "Dawn (Go Away)" sat right next to those original Beatles hits. And when summer came around, so did "I Get Around."
So Frankie already seems dead. Mouthing the words as numerous people carry the tune behind him. And one time they introduce him and he's frozen on the steps to the stage and... The internet said it was elder abuse. Frankie responded that he's got all his marbles. He doesn't, at least he can't hear and sing, but he can't give up that hit from the audience, it's even more important than the money.
Anyway, I'd say that "Nobody Wants This is" is the new "Sex and the City," but that's not exactly true. "Nobody Wants This" is less of a fantasy, and it's based on a true story.
So Kristen Bell and Justine Lupe are sisters with a podcast, who hope that Spotify will ink them to a rich and famous deal. As the series progresses, you'll fall in love with Lupe. Because she radiates thickness and sharpness at the same time. I mean you think she's a dumb blonde, but she's not, over the ten episodes you realize she's loyal and dedicated and perceptive. I'd say she's the heart of the show, but really that's about the relationship between Kristen Bell and Adam Brody, the shiksa and the rabbi.
Yes, Adam Brody is a rabbi. Not that Kristen Bell realizes this until after she falls for him, is intrigued. And he's off limits...or is he?
And when you're Bell/Joanne's age, your criteria are different. When you're in your middle thirties if it can't possibly lead to marriage, you nip it in the bud.
As for Bell... I really only know her from "Forgetting Sarah Marshall." And I'm aware that she's married to now podcaster Dax Shepard. But I know her visage well enough to know...she looks different. I know, I know, it's illegal to comment on women's looks, I get it, but it was off-putting. There's a whole thread about it on Reddit. I just couldn't stop thinking about it.
And to the degree I know her, Bell plays against type. She isn't the puppy dog ingenue. She's an edgy woman who is unaware of her foibles who can't have a relationship. Bell definitely plays an adult here. And other than her physical image, it rings true. She's grown up.
As for Adam Brody...
Before the show I couldn't have picked him out of a lineup. I never watched "The O.C.," and in terms of names, I always confuse him with Adrien Brody, even though they're nothing alike. But Brody is masterful here. Because he underplays, which means he acts like someone in real life. He's not so madly in love that he engages in over the top demonstrations, and he will not forgo his rabbinical duties to chase Bell/Joanne and...
He rings true.
Now the dance, the beginning of a relationship, the infatuation, the doubt, is done extremely well in "Nobody Wants This." They nail it. The first two episodes had me over the moon.
As for what came after... I wasn't as enamored, then again was it my mood?
So there's a certain amount of Jewish shtick, that will crack you up if you're a member of the tribe. Brody/Noah's parents want to know where Joanne went to school. Bingo!
And as much as Joanne is reluctant to go further with Noah...
Noah is just out of a relationship. You see his fiancée wanted it too much, was two, if not three or four steps ahead, she had their life completely planned out. Push men at your peril. And although Rebecca is a caricature at first, she becomes fully developed thereafter.
And what does Noah owe Rebecca?
And his brother's wife is her best friend... And both she and he don't completely ring true. Timothy Simons as Sasha Roklov is too over the top, too much comic relief until he ends up connecting with Lupe/Morgan near the end of the show, and then he becomes real.
But one thing is for sure, Sasha's wife Esther, Jackie Tohn, wears the pants in the family.
As for Tovah Feldshuh, she's always great. And will not accept Joanne, that's not what she wants for her boy. Mine were different, but Jewish parents are famous for meddling in their children's lives. I can't tell you how many people I know who became doctors and lawyers because their parents told them to/made them. Hell, even I went to law school! But I jumped the track, or never really laid down in it, but so many lived their parents' lives when really, they wanted to do something else.
And intermarriage is not the huge issue it once was. But if you're a rabbi... And if you are in a mixed marriage, or thinking of entering one, know that it's very important for Jewish people, especially the parents, that the children be raised Jewish.
Now when we dove in a week ago, "Nobody Wants This" was #1 on Netflix. As I write this, it's #3. But this success is not palpable, you can't feel it in the world at large.
Remember when "Friends" was triumphant? There were reams of stories, but that's not how it works anymore. Netflix doesn't need that, it just needs you paying your monthly subscription. And the media is detached from reality. The outlets are all about the new shows on network. I literally can't tell you the last time I watched a series on network, I'm pretty sure it's the last century. You see you can't do visceral on network, and that edge is what resonates with the public.
"Nobody Wants This" is almost a stealth hit.
And it's not a huge commitment. Ten episodes, most of them not even half an hour long. You get to know the characters and you can burn through the episodes and...
This is the way television is supposed to be.
It's hard to do comedy. But you'd expect it on Netflix first, where the sieve is not so narrow, where the suits don't unduly interfere.
I know, the concept seems too artificial, so broad, so ridiculous that you might shy away. Don't.
The RottenTomatoes ratings have come down since we watched, a week ago they were both in the 90s, today they're 95/88. But that's still damn good.
Will you love "Nobody Wants This"? Will you even like it?
I don't know, but odds are you'll prefer it to the rest of the dreck out there.
Check it out.
--
Visit the archive: http://lefsetz.com/wordpress/
--
Listen to the podcast:
-iHeart: https://ihr.fm/2Gi5PFj
-Apple: https://apple.co/2ndmpvp
--
http://www.twitter.com/lefsetz
--
If you would like to subscribe to the LefsetzLetter,
http://www.lefsetz.com/lists/?p=subscribe&id=1
If you do not want to receive any more LefsetzLetters, http://lefsetz.com/lists/?p=unsubscribe&uid=0eecea7b60b461717065cbde887c8e25
To change your email address http://lefsetz.com/lists/?p=preferences&uid=0eecea7b60b461717065cbde887c8e25
We watched this because Brooke Hammerling raved about it.
I was aware of the Netflix series, but the reviews said it missed the mark. The first few were negative, the next said the series was fun, but a trifle, and then I saw Brooke mention "Nobody Wants This" in Pop Culture Mondays. You can read it/sign up for it, here: https://popculturemondays.com
But let me just tell you, it's a lot of stuff. And if you're a social media hater, someone who believes the smartphone is best turned off, you'll scroll what Brooke has to say and be flummoxed, overwhelmed and ultimately dismissive. You see Brooke chronicles social media/internet trends.
Did you see those Frankie Valli videos?
I hadn't, although I did catch some of the aftermath after being hipped by Brooke.
You see Frankie Valli is 90 and still on the road. I heard over a decade ago that he lip-synchs, so I've avoided the show, because I love the Four Seasons, my mother bought "Big Girls Don't Cry" and that was just about the only pop record she ever purchased. And when the Beatles hit, the American acts that persevered, that got not only radio play but jukebox play, were the Four Seasons and the Beach Boys. "Dawn (Go Away)" sat right next to those original Beatles hits. And when summer came around, so did "I Get Around."
So Frankie already seems dead. Mouthing the words as numerous people carry the tune behind him. And one time they introduce him and he's frozen on the steps to the stage and... The internet said it was elder abuse. Frankie responded that he's got all his marbles. He doesn't, at least he can't hear and sing, but he can't give up that hit from the audience, it's even more important than the money.
Anyway, I'd say that "Nobody Wants This is" is the new "Sex and the City," but that's not exactly true. "Nobody Wants This" is less of a fantasy, and it's based on a true story.
So Kristen Bell and Justine Lupe are sisters with a podcast, who hope that Spotify will ink them to a rich and famous deal. As the series progresses, you'll fall in love with Lupe. Because she radiates thickness and sharpness at the same time. I mean you think she's a dumb blonde, but she's not, over the ten episodes you realize she's loyal and dedicated and perceptive. I'd say she's the heart of the show, but really that's about the relationship between Kristen Bell and Adam Brody, the shiksa and the rabbi.
Yes, Adam Brody is a rabbi. Not that Kristen Bell realizes this until after she falls for him, is intrigued. And he's off limits...or is he?
And when you're Bell/Joanne's age, your criteria are different. When you're in your middle thirties if it can't possibly lead to marriage, you nip it in the bud.
As for Bell... I really only know her from "Forgetting Sarah Marshall." And I'm aware that she's married to now podcaster Dax Shepard. But I know her visage well enough to know...she looks different. I know, I know, it's illegal to comment on women's looks, I get it, but it was off-putting. There's a whole thread about it on Reddit. I just couldn't stop thinking about it.
And to the degree I know her, Bell plays against type. She isn't the puppy dog ingenue. She's an edgy woman who is unaware of her foibles who can't have a relationship. Bell definitely plays an adult here. And other than her physical image, it rings true. She's grown up.
As for Adam Brody...
Before the show I couldn't have picked him out of a lineup. I never watched "The O.C.," and in terms of names, I always confuse him with Adrien Brody, even though they're nothing alike. But Brody is masterful here. Because he underplays, which means he acts like someone in real life. He's not so madly in love that he engages in over the top demonstrations, and he will not forgo his rabbinical duties to chase Bell/Joanne and...
He rings true.
Now the dance, the beginning of a relationship, the infatuation, the doubt, is done extremely well in "Nobody Wants This." They nail it. The first two episodes had me over the moon.
As for what came after... I wasn't as enamored, then again was it my mood?
So there's a certain amount of Jewish shtick, that will crack you up if you're a member of the tribe. Brody/Noah's parents want to know where Joanne went to school. Bingo!
And as much as Joanne is reluctant to go further with Noah...
Noah is just out of a relationship. You see his fiancée wanted it too much, was two, if not three or four steps ahead, she had their life completely planned out. Push men at your peril. And although Rebecca is a caricature at first, she becomes fully developed thereafter.
And what does Noah owe Rebecca?
And his brother's wife is her best friend... And both she and he don't completely ring true. Timothy Simons as Sasha Roklov is too over the top, too much comic relief until he ends up connecting with Lupe/Morgan near the end of the show, and then he becomes real.
But one thing is for sure, Sasha's wife Esther, Jackie Tohn, wears the pants in the family.
As for Tovah Feldshuh, she's always great. And will not accept Joanne, that's not what she wants for her boy. Mine were different, but Jewish parents are famous for meddling in their children's lives. I can't tell you how many people I know who became doctors and lawyers because their parents told them to/made them. Hell, even I went to law school! But I jumped the track, or never really laid down in it, but so many lived their parents' lives when really, they wanted to do something else.
And intermarriage is not the huge issue it once was. But if you're a rabbi... And if you are in a mixed marriage, or thinking of entering one, know that it's very important for Jewish people, especially the parents, that the children be raised Jewish.
Now when we dove in a week ago, "Nobody Wants This" was #1 on Netflix. As I write this, it's #3. But this success is not palpable, you can't feel it in the world at large.
Remember when "Friends" was triumphant? There were reams of stories, but that's not how it works anymore. Netflix doesn't need that, it just needs you paying your monthly subscription. And the media is detached from reality. The outlets are all about the new shows on network. I literally can't tell you the last time I watched a series on network, I'm pretty sure it's the last century. You see you can't do visceral on network, and that edge is what resonates with the public.
"Nobody Wants This" is almost a stealth hit.
And it's not a huge commitment. Ten episodes, most of them not even half an hour long. You get to know the characters and you can burn through the episodes and...
This is the way television is supposed to be.
It's hard to do comedy. But you'd expect it on Netflix first, where the sieve is not so narrow, where the suits don't unduly interfere.
I know, the concept seems too artificial, so broad, so ridiculous that you might shy away. Don't.
The RottenTomatoes ratings have come down since we watched, a week ago they were both in the 90s, today they're 95/88. But that's still damn good.
Will you love "Nobody Wants This"? Will you even like it?
I don't know, but odds are you'll prefer it to the rest of the dreck out there.
Check it out.
--
Visit the archive: http://lefsetz.com/wordpress/
--
Listen to the podcast:
-iHeart: https://ihr.fm/2Gi5PFj
-Apple: https://apple.co/2ndmpvp
--
http://www.twitter.com/lefsetz
--
If you would like to subscribe to the LefsetzLetter,
http://www.lefsetz.com/lists/?p=subscribe&id=1
If you do not want to receive any more LefsetzLetters, http://lefsetz.com/lists/?p=unsubscribe&uid=0eecea7b60b461717065cbde887c8e25
To change your email address http://lefsetz.com/lists/?p=preferences&uid=0eecea7b60b461717065cbde887c8e25
Sunday 6 October 2024
Israel/Hezbollah/Iran/Gaza
The last month has defined the issues.
The "Washington Post" has been doing incredible work. The paper may not be profitable, but it's definitely worth reading. Yesterday there was this story:
"Hamas built an underground war machine to ensure its own survival - Vowing self-sufficiency, Hamas turned a maze of tunnels in Gaza into weapons factories and well-stocked fortifications. A year after the war began, parts of the group remain deeply entrenched."
Free link: https://wapo.st/3Ycthfj
This is what Israel is up against. No matter which side you are on, you'll find this investigation of Hamas's war effort both illuminating and fascinating. The most important point is that the weapons were not being shipped from Iran, they were not coming through the border with Egypt, rather Hamas was building their arsenal, their rockets, from scratch in their tunnels. No one knew this previously, unless you were in Hamas yourself. And if you were, you were aware that a big action was coming, they'd been planning October 7th for years.
And in today's "Washington Post" there's another deep dive:
"Mossad's pager operation: Inside Israel's penetration of Hezbollah - New details emerge of Israel's elaborate plan to sabotage Hezbollah communications devices to kill or maim thousands of its operatives."
Free link: https://wapo.st/3NfkRNV
This is what the denigrated mainstream media does. Investigate, tell the story, but those on both the right and left hate the "New York Times" and there's not a whole lot of respect for the WaPo or the "Wall Street Journal" either. TV news is the land of opinion. And that's what you get in the scuttlebutt online. The internet has unleashed everybody's fury. Everybody's got an opinion and everybody wants to express it and everything is up for grabs. Most of America believes there is no truth, or won't listen to a contrary opinion. I must admit that the right was correct about college campuses, they're indoctrinating students into an us vs. them perspective, where those with money and power are the enemy, no matter what their bona fides and efforts might be. Sometimes those with the power are not the oppressor, sometimes the little guy is just plain wrong, or a terrorist.
For one year hate has been rained down upon Israel and the Jews. And don't separate them, because the haters don't. On the UCLA campus Jews were labeled Zionists irrelevant of their beliefs and prevented from passing and so much more. So when people tell you it's only Israel they hate, don't believe them.
As for those against Israel, I point you to this article in the "New York Times":
"Pro-Palestinian Group Is Relentless in Its Criticism of Israel, and It Isn't Backing Down - Within Our Lifetime, a group formed by New York students, has galvanized pro-Palestinian activists who are calling for the end of Israel — and facing accusations of antisemitism."
Free link: https://t.ly/TQdo9
Once again, the actions in Lebanon and the rocket attack by Iran have defined the issues very clearly.
It used to be about the poor people in Gaza, victims of the bloody, genocidal Israelis.
But now that the war has spread to Lebanon, people have become aware of what Israel is up against.
So what you've got here, in America anyway, if not the world, is the Palestine or die people, those who think the Israelis should get out of Gaza, and should be prosecuted for war crimes while they give their country up to the Palestinians, from the river to the sea baby, and those who support Israel and its actions, and those who either don't care or are afraid to take a side for fear of some retribution, some loss. Israel has been defined as the bully here, the aggressor, even though Hamas attacked the Jewish homeland, and if you say otherwise...
Even Biden and Harris are afraid of the pro-Palestinian posse. They're pussyfooting, fearful of alienating anyone who might vote blue. Forget doing what is right, one must question how big the anti-Israel/pro-Palestine group really is. Do you kowtow to a vocal minority?
So now that Israel blew up pagers and walkie-talkies and then bombed Hezbollah in Lebanon...
People can get the complete picture. Israelis in the north had spent months in retreat from their homes because of bombing by Hezbollah. Netanyahu, possibly the most hated person on the face of the earth, who engenders more vitriol than Ticketmaster, decided that this could no longer be the case, he wanted his population to be able to go back to their homes. Which meant fighting Hezbollah, which like Hamas, is a terrorist group.
In Lebanon there were cheers and jeers when Nasrallah was killed. So many of the rank and file were sick of living under Hezbollah, which isn't even the government.
And in Gaza... It's the same. But you don't hear any contrary opinion, any outcry from the residents, because that will set you up for not only reprisal, but probably death.
Now one thing has been made perfectly clear. Most of the media has no idea what is happening in the Middle East, never mind the public at large.
We've been subjected to Thomas Friedman's bloviations about peace and a two state solution for the entire year. But this is not what the Palestinians, want, they want Israel GONE!
As do a lot of the protesters in the U.S.
But now everybody can see what is really going on.
Iran is behind the terrorists, otherwise why would the Ayatollah bomb Israel?
So do you lay your arms down, as even Macron is urging today...
Or you can be the United States, which gets into wars and never wins, ultimately retreats. I mean if you're going to fight, why do so if you're afraid of going all the way to victory?
But the United States is not Israel.
As for Netanyahu and Israel, they're far from perfect. But now it's perfectly clear, that it's not only Hamas in Gaza, but the Palestinians and the Iranians and the Yemenites too want Israel wiped from the face of the earth.
It's no longer about collateral damage in Gaza. Innocent people dying.
Now we're down to the real nitty gritty.
So you may hate Israel and the Jews. You're entitled to. But when you're out protesting on behalf of Palestinians it's now clear it's not only about saving the supposed innocent, but hamstringing Israel, believing that the Palestinians have greater rights to the land than the Jews.
As for the Jews... For so many years, decades, young Americans were not exposed to antisemitism. I'm not saying it didn't exist, I'm saying it wasn't palpable. But now it is. And now the battle is more than Gaza. So if you're a Jew and siding with the Palestinians...
Nobody likes war, nobody likes innocent people dying. But sometimes you're attacked and have to respond, which is all Israel did in Gaza and Lebanon. And the nature of war is innocent people dying, ask the Allies about Dresden.
As for the America First people... Israel is our only bastion in the Middle East. You want a Christian nation? You have no idea how many Muslims are on the planet, you can't put your head in the ground. Is every Muslim a terrorist? Of course not, but Hamas and Hezbollah are.
And then you've got the situation in Ukraine. The ultimate domino. Take your finger out of the dike and who knows what other Russian satellites of yore Putin goes after.
Would I like to watch Netflix and listen to music, ignore all this?
And it's really not that complicated, even though it is controversial. You either support Israel or you do not. There's no halfway anymore. You can't say you support Israel but believe the war in Gaza must stop because of the havoc on the general population... Now you either want Israel to survive or you don't. Which side are you on?
You get to choose.
Then again, if you're pro-Israel, if you flaunt your Jewish heritage, watch out on college campuses. If Blacks were oppressed like Jews it would have been stopped immediately. But when it's Jews...
Do you see this outcry when people are killed in Sudan or Syria?
Of course not.
Because it's about the Jews.
And now it's perfectly clear. You can't hide behind humanitarianism anymore. Now the issues are palpable, defined. The terrorists against the Jews. America's ally against a network of Middle Eastern nations that want Israel literally wiped from the map.
Once again, you're entitled to believe whatever you want. Best if you familiarize yourself with the facts, but when has that stopped anybody in the social media age.
And fearful Jews... There's talk about an election of Trump being the end of democracy, if Israel goes, where does it leave the Jews? Now if you're a victim of antisemitism you can go to Israel, but if the country doesn't exist...
So ironically, by doubling-down in his efforts against terrorists, Netanyahu has helped his case. Now the issues are black and white. Are you for Israel and what it takes for the country to survive?
Or not.
But Israel has money and American support and all that technology... The war is just not fair!
Since when has war been fair?
So now when you see the Palestinian protest in your neighborhood know... This is not about the death of innocents, this is about the hatred of Israel and the Jews.
And believe me, it's been a long game. Just like Hamas in Gaza, as delineated in that article. BDS was started by the Palestinians, they penetrated college campuses while the Israelis were asleep. To the point where even Jews were in support of the plight of the Palestinians...
But now?
Don't tell me about the rank and file, who might be ready to step up for Hamas as put forth in the first article. The bottom line is Israel is fighting terrorists, well-funded terrorists, but so many in the world believe they need to lay down their arms and...negotiate? The Palestinians have been offered their own country again and again, but have rejected this, because they insist that Israel must go.
If you read the reviled mainstream press, this would be clear.
But today too many live in self-reflecting echo chambers.
The truth is the world is a complicated place. And sometimes the solution is not easy, sometimes you have to defend yourself. You wish you didn't have to, but if their goal is not only your defeat, but your extinction, is there really a choice?
I haven't been to Israel in fifty years. I can't remember the last time I was in a shul. As for belief in God? Judaism is a questioning religion, you don't have to believe in God to be a member of the tribe.
As for all this horsesh*t, this blowback because the Jews are supposedly the "Chosen People"... I mean if you're not laughing... This is what every underdog, every marginalized people do to puff themselves up against strong odds. If you think the average Jew believes themselves to be special and entitled...you don't know many Jews, and if there are Jews who believe this, they're delusional.
But I have relatives who left Russia for Israel. They avoided the ovens. They got out early. They saw the handwriting on the wall.
If you're a Jew and you don't see the handwriting on the wall today...
When are you going to make a stand? When they've got a knife at your throat?
I don't want more, I just want what everybody else does, a safe life and the ability to prosper.
But if you're a Jew...
Now it's all out in the open. Now it's clear. Now is the time to speak up.
And I just did.
--
Visit the archive: http://lefsetz.com/wordpress/
--
Listen to the podcast:
-iHeart: https://ihr.fm/2Gi5PFj
-Apple: https://apple.co/2ndmpvp
--
http://www.twitter.com/lefsetz
--
If you would like to subscribe to the LefsetzLetter,
http://www.lefsetz.com/lists/?p=subscribe&id=1
If you do not want to receive any more LefsetzLetters, http://lefsetz.com/lists/?p=unsubscribe&uid=0eecea7b60b461717065cbde887c8e25
To change your email address http://lefsetz.com/lists/?p=preferences&uid=0eecea7b60b461717065cbde887c8e25
The "Washington Post" has been doing incredible work. The paper may not be profitable, but it's definitely worth reading. Yesterday there was this story:
"Hamas built an underground war machine to ensure its own survival - Vowing self-sufficiency, Hamas turned a maze of tunnels in Gaza into weapons factories and well-stocked fortifications. A year after the war began, parts of the group remain deeply entrenched."
Free link: https://wapo.st/3Ycthfj
This is what Israel is up against. No matter which side you are on, you'll find this investigation of Hamas's war effort both illuminating and fascinating. The most important point is that the weapons were not being shipped from Iran, they were not coming through the border with Egypt, rather Hamas was building their arsenal, their rockets, from scratch in their tunnels. No one knew this previously, unless you were in Hamas yourself. And if you were, you were aware that a big action was coming, they'd been planning October 7th for years.
And in today's "Washington Post" there's another deep dive:
"Mossad's pager operation: Inside Israel's penetration of Hezbollah - New details emerge of Israel's elaborate plan to sabotage Hezbollah communications devices to kill or maim thousands of its operatives."
Free link: https://wapo.st/3NfkRNV
This is what the denigrated mainstream media does. Investigate, tell the story, but those on both the right and left hate the "New York Times" and there's not a whole lot of respect for the WaPo or the "Wall Street Journal" either. TV news is the land of opinion. And that's what you get in the scuttlebutt online. The internet has unleashed everybody's fury. Everybody's got an opinion and everybody wants to express it and everything is up for grabs. Most of America believes there is no truth, or won't listen to a contrary opinion. I must admit that the right was correct about college campuses, they're indoctrinating students into an us vs. them perspective, where those with money and power are the enemy, no matter what their bona fides and efforts might be. Sometimes those with the power are not the oppressor, sometimes the little guy is just plain wrong, or a terrorist.
For one year hate has been rained down upon Israel and the Jews. And don't separate them, because the haters don't. On the UCLA campus Jews were labeled Zionists irrelevant of their beliefs and prevented from passing and so much more. So when people tell you it's only Israel they hate, don't believe them.
As for those against Israel, I point you to this article in the "New York Times":
"Pro-Palestinian Group Is Relentless in Its Criticism of Israel, and It Isn't Backing Down - Within Our Lifetime, a group formed by New York students, has galvanized pro-Palestinian activists who are calling for the end of Israel — and facing accusations of antisemitism."
Free link: https://t.ly/TQdo9
Once again, the actions in Lebanon and the rocket attack by Iran have defined the issues very clearly.
It used to be about the poor people in Gaza, victims of the bloody, genocidal Israelis.
But now that the war has spread to Lebanon, people have become aware of what Israel is up against.
So what you've got here, in America anyway, if not the world, is the Palestine or die people, those who think the Israelis should get out of Gaza, and should be prosecuted for war crimes while they give their country up to the Palestinians, from the river to the sea baby, and those who support Israel and its actions, and those who either don't care or are afraid to take a side for fear of some retribution, some loss. Israel has been defined as the bully here, the aggressor, even though Hamas attacked the Jewish homeland, and if you say otherwise...
Even Biden and Harris are afraid of the pro-Palestinian posse. They're pussyfooting, fearful of alienating anyone who might vote blue. Forget doing what is right, one must question how big the anti-Israel/pro-Palestine group really is. Do you kowtow to a vocal minority?
So now that Israel blew up pagers and walkie-talkies and then bombed Hezbollah in Lebanon...
People can get the complete picture. Israelis in the north had spent months in retreat from their homes because of bombing by Hezbollah. Netanyahu, possibly the most hated person on the face of the earth, who engenders more vitriol than Ticketmaster, decided that this could no longer be the case, he wanted his population to be able to go back to their homes. Which meant fighting Hezbollah, which like Hamas, is a terrorist group.
In Lebanon there were cheers and jeers when Nasrallah was killed. So many of the rank and file were sick of living under Hezbollah, which isn't even the government.
And in Gaza... It's the same. But you don't hear any contrary opinion, any outcry from the residents, because that will set you up for not only reprisal, but probably death.
Now one thing has been made perfectly clear. Most of the media has no idea what is happening in the Middle East, never mind the public at large.
We've been subjected to Thomas Friedman's bloviations about peace and a two state solution for the entire year. But this is not what the Palestinians, want, they want Israel GONE!
As do a lot of the protesters in the U.S.
But now everybody can see what is really going on.
Iran is behind the terrorists, otherwise why would the Ayatollah bomb Israel?
So do you lay your arms down, as even Macron is urging today...
Or you can be the United States, which gets into wars and never wins, ultimately retreats. I mean if you're going to fight, why do so if you're afraid of going all the way to victory?
But the United States is not Israel.
As for Netanyahu and Israel, they're far from perfect. But now it's perfectly clear, that it's not only Hamas in Gaza, but the Palestinians and the Iranians and the Yemenites too want Israel wiped from the face of the earth.
It's no longer about collateral damage in Gaza. Innocent people dying.
Now we're down to the real nitty gritty.
So you may hate Israel and the Jews. You're entitled to. But when you're out protesting on behalf of Palestinians it's now clear it's not only about saving the supposed innocent, but hamstringing Israel, believing that the Palestinians have greater rights to the land than the Jews.
As for the Jews... For so many years, decades, young Americans were not exposed to antisemitism. I'm not saying it didn't exist, I'm saying it wasn't palpable. But now it is. And now the battle is more than Gaza. So if you're a Jew and siding with the Palestinians...
Nobody likes war, nobody likes innocent people dying. But sometimes you're attacked and have to respond, which is all Israel did in Gaza and Lebanon. And the nature of war is innocent people dying, ask the Allies about Dresden.
As for the America First people... Israel is our only bastion in the Middle East. You want a Christian nation? You have no idea how many Muslims are on the planet, you can't put your head in the ground. Is every Muslim a terrorist? Of course not, but Hamas and Hezbollah are.
And then you've got the situation in Ukraine. The ultimate domino. Take your finger out of the dike and who knows what other Russian satellites of yore Putin goes after.
Would I like to watch Netflix and listen to music, ignore all this?
And it's really not that complicated, even though it is controversial. You either support Israel or you do not. There's no halfway anymore. You can't say you support Israel but believe the war in Gaza must stop because of the havoc on the general population... Now you either want Israel to survive or you don't. Which side are you on?
You get to choose.
Then again, if you're pro-Israel, if you flaunt your Jewish heritage, watch out on college campuses. If Blacks were oppressed like Jews it would have been stopped immediately. But when it's Jews...
Do you see this outcry when people are killed in Sudan or Syria?
Of course not.
Because it's about the Jews.
And now it's perfectly clear. You can't hide behind humanitarianism anymore. Now the issues are palpable, defined. The terrorists against the Jews. America's ally against a network of Middle Eastern nations that want Israel literally wiped from the map.
Once again, you're entitled to believe whatever you want. Best if you familiarize yourself with the facts, but when has that stopped anybody in the social media age.
And fearful Jews... There's talk about an election of Trump being the end of democracy, if Israel goes, where does it leave the Jews? Now if you're a victim of antisemitism you can go to Israel, but if the country doesn't exist...
So ironically, by doubling-down in his efforts against terrorists, Netanyahu has helped his case. Now the issues are black and white. Are you for Israel and what it takes for the country to survive?
Or not.
But Israel has money and American support and all that technology... The war is just not fair!
Since when has war been fair?
So now when you see the Palestinian protest in your neighborhood know... This is not about the death of innocents, this is about the hatred of Israel and the Jews.
And believe me, it's been a long game. Just like Hamas in Gaza, as delineated in that article. BDS was started by the Palestinians, they penetrated college campuses while the Israelis were asleep. To the point where even Jews were in support of the plight of the Palestinians...
But now?
Don't tell me about the rank and file, who might be ready to step up for Hamas as put forth in the first article. The bottom line is Israel is fighting terrorists, well-funded terrorists, but so many in the world believe they need to lay down their arms and...negotiate? The Palestinians have been offered their own country again and again, but have rejected this, because they insist that Israel must go.
If you read the reviled mainstream press, this would be clear.
But today too many live in self-reflecting echo chambers.
The truth is the world is a complicated place. And sometimes the solution is not easy, sometimes you have to defend yourself. You wish you didn't have to, but if their goal is not only your defeat, but your extinction, is there really a choice?
I haven't been to Israel in fifty years. I can't remember the last time I was in a shul. As for belief in God? Judaism is a questioning religion, you don't have to believe in God to be a member of the tribe.
As for all this horsesh*t, this blowback because the Jews are supposedly the "Chosen People"... I mean if you're not laughing... This is what every underdog, every marginalized people do to puff themselves up against strong odds. If you think the average Jew believes themselves to be special and entitled...you don't know many Jews, and if there are Jews who believe this, they're delusional.
But I have relatives who left Russia for Israel. They avoided the ovens. They got out early. They saw the handwriting on the wall.
If you're a Jew and you don't see the handwriting on the wall today...
When are you going to make a stand? When they've got a knife at your throat?
I don't want more, I just want what everybody else does, a safe life and the ability to prosper.
But if you're a Jew...
Now it's all out in the open. Now it's clear. Now is the time to speak up.
And I just did.
--
Visit the archive: http://lefsetz.com/wordpress/
--
Listen to the podcast:
-iHeart: https://ihr.fm/2Gi5PFj
-Apple: https://apple.co/2ndmpvp
--
http://www.twitter.com/lefsetz
--
If you would like to subscribe to the LefsetzLetter,
http://www.lefsetz.com/lists/?p=subscribe&id=1
If you do not want to receive any more LefsetzLetters, http://lefsetz.com/lists/?p=unsubscribe&uid=0eecea7b60b461717065cbde887c8e25
To change your email address http://lefsetz.com/lists/?p=preferences&uid=0eecea7b60b461717065cbde887c8e25
Zach Bryan Opts Out
"Zach Bryan Is Absent From 2025 Grammy Ballot, as He Joins the Superstar Ranks of Drake and the Weeknd in Declining to Submit"
https://t.ly/vzfZn
And that's why he's such a big star.
When the Eagles sing we haven't had that spirit here since 1969, this is what they're talking about.
This is what made music so powerful, not Lady Gaga in a lame Hollywood movie, but those who were on their own path, away from the mainstream, thinking for themselves, which is why everybody followed them.
Bryan is in tune with the times. People are sick of the construct, they feel marginalized, they want someone to believe in.
This is the antidote to Kardashianism, that was so 2010s.
The story of the past ten years, the Trump ascendance, is that people are questioning institutions and the people who run them. Like Hillary Clinton. They want someone new, someone to lead them, someone to believe in. That was not Trump, but he tapped into a feeling, the zeitgeist of today's America, meanwhile, historical institutions like the Grammys double-down like they still count, oblivious. He not busy being born is busy dying? That's what Bob Dylan sang, meanwhile the Grammys are calcified. They can't even eliminate categories for fear some marginalized musician will complain they don't have an opportunity to win a statuette.
I could continue to trash the Grammys, but what's the point.
The point is music can be our number one cultural driver, no art form is as powerful, but it requires artists to think for themselves, out of the box.
One of the great things about the decimation of the major labels is that now acts don't have to listen to suits tell them what to do. This is the way it was in the late sixties and seventies. The suits finally realized they didn't know, the acts were in control, they just delivered finished albums, there was no remixing, none of the constant drone about a hit single...
There's this canard that music is a commodity. That the major labels are stewards of what is popular now. That's business, not art. And never confuse them.
There is no artistic competition. It's a faux construct. Who is better, Picasso or Braque or Pollock or... Picasso kept changing, knowing that to stay stuck in a rut is anathema. Pollock threw out the entire rulebook forget traditional representation.
Imagine a TV painting competition. Couldn't be done. What are the criteria for excellence? How long does someone get? But now too much music is made on an assembly line.
Meanwhile, when the outside triumphs, it's good for everyone. Chappell Roan is good for everyone. Because she's not a tween from a TV show singing songs written by committee.
And in country age is no longer a barrier.
And the most revered man in country, who is also very successful, is 46 and overweight.
You have to be able to say no. You have to be able to question convention and authority. You must think for yourself and risk.
This is what the public is looking for from artists.
Artistry knows no bounds. It's about inspiration, vision. Not some committee deciding whether you're good or bad.
We need more artists pulling out of the Grammys as opposed to those complaining they're not winning awards.
A Grammy is meaningless. A song that changes someone's life is not.
If your obituary says how many Grammys you won, either you missed the point or the writer did.
We live in a bottom up society. Think of what the public wants. When you hang with celebrities and are featured in TMZ, when you flaunt your lifestyle, when you start selling us perfume and brandy...you may be making money, but you're missing the point.
That's got nothing to do with music.
And the money goes to those who focus on music, and only music.
Because when you do this, when you are uncompromised, people believe in you, FOREVER! You can pursue your art FOREVER!
Music is not about the momentary, it's about careers, those who explore and last.
The stars should exist in their own world, outside the corporation, beacons to the people.
Which is what Zach Bryan does, which is why he succeeds.
--
Visit the archive: http://lefsetz.com/wordpress/
--
Listen to the podcast:
-iHeart: https://ihr.fm/2Gi5PFj
-Apple: https://apple.co/2ndmpvp
--
http://www.twitter.com/lefsetz
--
If you would like to subscribe to the LefsetzLetter,
http://www.lefsetz.com/lists/?p=subscribe&id=1
If you do not want to receive any more LefsetzLetters, http://lefsetz.com/lists/?p=unsubscribe&uid=0eecea7b60b461717065cbde887c8e25
To change your email address http://lefsetz.com/lists/?p=preferences&uid=0eecea7b60b461717065cbde887c8e25
https://t.ly/vzfZn
And that's why he's such a big star.
When the Eagles sing we haven't had that spirit here since 1969, this is what they're talking about.
This is what made music so powerful, not Lady Gaga in a lame Hollywood movie, but those who were on their own path, away from the mainstream, thinking for themselves, which is why everybody followed them.
Bryan is in tune with the times. People are sick of the construct, they feel marginalized, they want someone to believe in.
This is the antidote to Kardashianism, that was so 2010s.
The story of the past ten years, the Trump ascendance, is that people are questioning institutions and the people who run them. Like Hillary Clinton. They want someone new, someone to lead them, someone to believe in. That was not Trump, but he tapped into a feeling, the zeitgeist of today's America, meanwhile, historical institutions like the Grammys double-down like they still count, oblivious. He not busy being born is busy dying? That's what Bob Dylan sang, meanwhile the Grammys are calcified. They can't even eliminate categories for fear some marginalized musician will complain they don't have an opportunity to win a statuette.
I could continue to trash the Grammys, but what's the point.
The point is music can be our number one cultural driver, no art form is as powerful, but it requires artists to think for themselves, out of the box.
One of the great things about the decimation of the major labels is that now acts don't have to listen to suits tell them what to do. This is the way it was in the late sixties and seventies. The suits finally realized they didn't know, the acts were in control, they just delivered finished albums, there was no remixing, none of the constant drone about a hit single...
There's this canard that music is a commodity. That the major labels are stewards of what is popular now. That's business, not art. And never confuse them.
There is no artistic competition. It's a faux construct. Who is better, Picasso or Braque or Pollock or... Picasso kept changing, knowing that to stay stuck in a rut is anathema. Pollock threw out the entire rulebook forget traditional representation.
Imagine a TV painting competition. Couldn't be done. What are the criteria for excellence? How long does someone get? But now too much music is made on an assembly line.
Meanwhile, when the outside triumphs, it's good for everyone. Chappell Roan is good for everyone. Because she's not a tween from a TV show singing songs written by committee.
And in country age is no longer a barrier.
And the most revered man in country, who is also very successful, is 46 and overweight.
You have to be able to say no. You have to be able to question convention and authority. You must think for yourself and risk.
This is what the public is looking for from artists.
Artistry knows no bounds. It's about inspiration, vision. Not some committee deciding whether you're good or bad.
We need more artists pulling out of the Grammys as opposed to those complaining they're not winning awards.
A Grammy is meaningless. A song that changes someone's life is not.
If your obituary says how many Grammys you won, either you missed the point or the writer did.
We live in a bottom up society. Think of what the public wants. When you hang with celebrities and are featured in TMZ, when you flaunt your lifestyle, when you start selling us perfume and brandy...you may be making money, but you're missing the point.
That's got nothing to do with music.
And the money goes to those who focus on music, and only music.
Because when you do this, when you are uncompromised, people believe in you, FOREVER! You can pursue your art FOREVER!
Music is not about the momentary, it's about careers, those who explore and last.
The stars should exist in their own world, outside the corporation, beacons to the people.
Which is what Zach Bryan does, which is why he succeeds.
--
Visit the archive: http://lefsetz.com/wordpress/
--
Listen to the podcast:
-iHeart: https://ihr.fm/2Gi5PFj
-Apple: https://apple.co/2ndmpvp
--
http://www.twitter.com/lefsetz
--
If you would like to subscribe to the LefsetzLetter,
http://www.lefsetz.com/lists/?p=subscribe&id=1
If you do not want to receive any more LefsetzLetters, http://lefsetz.com/lists/?p=unsubscribe&uid=0eecea7b60b461717065cbde887c8e25
To change your email address http://lefsetz.com/lists/?p=preferences&uid=0eecea7b60b461717065cbde887c8e25
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)