https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-X9dxL17t1k I'm stunned by the virality of this clip. In an era where that's the music industry's goal, and essentially unattainable, how did this brief video on a tired fifty year old TV program spread like wildfire through the culture, engendering analysis and comments both lowbrow and high? Most viral moments have train-wreck value. They're not radically different from "America's Funniest Home Videos." Pulling some kid's finger, a housewife wearing a "Star Wars" mask. Something that causes chuckles, that is spread over the course of a brief period of time, today merely days, which then disappears. Kind of like today's Spotify Top 50. And that's just the point. Now if you watch this SNL clip you won't roll on the floor laughing. Either you're so young that it will slide right off of you or it will resonate, have you chuckling, feeling validated, or make you squirm, depending upon whether you do or do not provide services to your elderly parents/love ones. In a visual world, "Sisters" resonates on an intellectual level. In a lowest common denominator world, where everything is smoothed for public consumption by the most people, "Sisters" resonates because it's so damn true. Like the best art, it reflects ourselves back upon us. Now I no longer watch SNL, at least not in real time. Having said that, if anything is good it shows up immediately on TikTok and Instagram Reels. Especially "Weekend Update," a segment that has maintained its gravitas, if you can say that about comedy. The problem with SNL is we've seen the trick. It's now all variation on a theme. There's a formula. With the aforementioned "Weekend Update" and a guest star monologue and two songs by a musical performer. You're not shocked, caught off guard, as you are in the fourth episode of the second season of "Black Doves," when all of a sudden you're jetted back to the past, three times, to get the backstories of characters. Then again, if you change it up, test limits, you risk failing. But it's always the outside stuff that breaks through and resonates, that changes the culture. Like the original SNL, the first five years. Believe me, the last thing a late teenager or twentysomething wanted to do on a Saturday night at 11:30 in the mid-seventies was watch television. You were out, testing limits. Sure, some people were home, but SNL got this slot because it was considered garbage time, with so few viewers advertising income was de minimis. But in a matter of months, certainly within a year, "Saturday Night Live" was appointment television. You STAYED HOME on Saturday night to watch it. VCRs were on the horizon, but back in the mid-seventies, if you didn't see it, you missed it. There was a similar phenomenon not quite a decade before, "Rowan & Martin's Laugh-In," also appointment television. It aired Monday night and you'd show up in school the next day uttering the catchphrases. But even though "Laugh-In" had Richard Nixon uttering "Sock it to me.," the edge was relatively dull. In an era experiencing a youthquake. Fully-recognized by the mid-seventies, it was the boomers world. And now they had their own TV show. From Belushi's samurai to the Coneheads... These became part of the cultural firmament, part of everyday conversation. And let's not forget that Belushi and Chevy Chase had truly broken through just a couple of years before with "National Lampoon: Lemmings," whose second half was a rock festival, a lampooning of Woodstock, with Belushi doing his impression of Joe Cocker. Never mind Mr. Mainway... But the world is different now. You don't have to settle for lowbrow entertainment. This is where Netflix has faltered, it made its bones on highbrow, "House of Cards," but they fired that content majordomo and have gone middlebrow ever since. You might get eyeballs for a while, but you don't get conversation, and "Sisters" causes conversation. After seeing it, you'll never forget it, because it resonates so totally. Then again, the past few decades have taught us if you want truth, you look to comedy, which is why standup is flourishing. You think someone wants to become a rock star? No, that's just the brain-dead who think a voice is enough, someone else will write the songs, these performers are essentially two-dimensional vessels. But a standup comedian? They're making it up from scratch, it's got to be original, it's THEM! And animation... Somehow cartoon characters can utter the truth humans are afraid to. But we all know the truth, we are foraging for it, looking to connect with it, hold it up, 24/7. This is the difference between business and art. The business people start at the end, the amount of money that can possibly be made. Whereas artists believe if the product/construct is good enough, if the subject is nailed, then money will come raining down. It's the exact ethos of the tech companies in the earlier part of this century. Google, Facebook, they all launched without a monetary model. But they were so good we not only used them, but told everybody about them. So seeing references to "Sisters" on social media, I was then confronted by articles in major news outlets. The "New York Times": "That 'S.N.L.' Sketch About Sister? It’s More Like Nonfiction - Saturday Night Live' exposed a truth about gender roles in caring for aging parents: While many nations have a federal safety net for older adults, the U.S. has sisters." https://www.nytimes.com/2026/11/18/upshot/sister-snl-elder-care.html?unlocked_article_code=1.SVE.xLoZ.6S2sfKk0cApX&smid=url-share The "Wall Street Journal": "How an SNL Sketch Sparked a National Conversation About Family Caregiving - SNL’s ‘Sister’ sketch is spurring millions of conversations about who should care for aging parents" https://www.wsj.com/health/wellness/snl-sister-caregiving-skit-3a6043e4?st=yN7YfB&reflink=desktopwebshare_permalink The "Guardian": "SNL’s skit Sister captures the quiet agony of caregiving for women: 'I’ve never felt seen like that' - The viral satirization of the caregiving burden left to women and daughters hit home for many viewers" https://www.theguardian.com/tv-and-radio/2026/nov/21/snl-sister-caregiving CNN, CNBC, "USA Today," "Forbes," the list goes on and on. We haven't had an artistic moment with this level of universal resonance since... Not "Barbie," not "The Odyssey," we got a lot of reviews, but despite the grosses, most Americans haven't seen these pictures. As for Taylor Swift? The only conversation you get inside the business is how much money she made. A deep analysis of the lyrics...are you kidding me? In one three minute clip, SNL channeled America, the veritable zeitgeist, and fed it back to us. And it turns out issues like this, family and caregiving, are the true universal ones, unlike ginned up controversies about trans and... And yes, the mainstream media does follow SNL, reports upon it, but usually the mainstream is last, it starts online, but this time the big outlets went on it immediately. Because they didn't see the clip as pablum, something nice for the kiddies, rather it made them think. Thinking, what a concept. Even Maureen Dowd weighed in, telling her own personal caregiving story: "The Sisterhood Rocks": https://www.nytimes.com/2026/11/21/opinion/sister-snl-family-care-parents.html?unlocked_article_code=1.SVE.OdfC.YeN4fBf0ZLD6&smid=url-share Let "Sisters" be a lesson. Don't trust the suits, but the artists, they need control. And the idea is more important than the execution, no one is talking about the production values of this clip, but the content, the message. And the subject is dangerous, going to raise conversation around the dinner table, sisters will feel emboldened and let loose their anger. What a change from the music business where every act is afraid of going on the record for fear of alienating a potential audience member. And what do all the writers of this clip have in common? THEY WENT TO COLLEGE! Whereas in music we promote the barely pubescent, with little to say. Now no one in this clip is going to get rich from doing it. Whereas when it comes to major label productions, that's the goal, otherwise they don't start. And even the wannabes are counting the potential money. We hear all about college being b.s., that they need to make it only three years, if it's necessary at all. But that is through the lens of big business, which sees college as a glorified finishing school, preparation for work. No, college is where you grow your mind, what you learn outside the classroom is more important than what you learn from the professor. Hanging in the dorm, meeting people from different backgrounds... "Sisters" is a triumph. Furthermore, you've got to give the creators credit for even coming up with the idea. I can't think of a single recent song that captures the essence of life here in the twenty first century so well. Let it be a beacon to you. -- Visit the archive: http://lefsetz.com/wordpress/ -- Listen to the podcast: -iHeart: https://ihr.fm/2Gi5PFj -Apple: https://apple.co/2ndmpvp -- http://www.twitter.com/lefsetz -- If you would like to subscribe to the LefsetzLetter, http://www.lefsetz.com/lists/?p=subscribe&id=1 If you do not want to receive any more LefsetzLetters, http://lefsetz.com/lists/?p=unsubscribe&uid=0eecea7b60b461717065cbde887c8e25 To change your email address http://lefsetz.com/lists/?p=preferences&uid=0eecea7b60b461717065cbde887c8e25
No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: only a member of this blog may post a comment.